As I was doing some spring cleaning over the last few weeks, I stumbled across a short story I wrote for English class in high school. The date, to be exact, was 12/3/1994. Upon seeing this story, I remembered sitting at the table writing this story, the creative juices flowing, and probably stressing about whether my teacher would find the story too weird!
The assignment was to write a story that met the following criteria: first person narrator who has a macabre obsession, follow a traditional plot line, and to use the ”Poe Vocabulary”. Apparently we were studying Poe at this time…I don’t have the copy of the story that was graded, and I have no clue what a traditional plot line is! The “Poe” words I incorporated are: dismembered, tour-de-force, and vexed. I don’t usually like criteria like that because it feels as if I am forcing a story to go in a certain direction, and it doesn’t let the story go in it’s own direction. I suppose it is possible, though, that it helped me shape this story and helped make it what it is. I feel as if this is still a work in progress, a long way from being “perfect”. But I’ve got time to work on it. In the meantime, I hope you enjoy the story!
————-
It’s 1:00 a.m. Who would knock on my door at this hour?
“Open up, Miller!” I heard a gruff sounding voice call from the other side of the door. I was scared. Who the hell was there, I thought as I stumbled through the darkness. I made it to the door, flipped the switch on the wall, and unlocked the dead bolt. I opened the door a crack and it strained against the chain of the second lock on the door. Two uniformed policemen stood in the hallway. I closed the door and dismantled the chain lock. What was going on? I hadn’t done anything wrong, or so I thought at the time.
In fact, looking back, I had done something wrong. I befriended a young girl. A young twelve year old girl. She was my student in the fifth grade. She was older than the other kids in my class because she had been hospitalized for two years and fell behind in her coursework. Because of her looks, she didn’t have many friends. She was tall, thin and gangly, and those characteristics combined with her long, straight black hair and dark, dreary eyes put the other students in the school on edge. When you looked at her, in her eyes, your thoughts turned to the macabre. But somehow, she was drawn to me and would open up to me about her life. She would stay after school almost every day and share her thoughts, feelings and emotions with me. I don’t remember much of what she told me except that during certain times throughout the day, she would have no memory of what she had been doing or how she ended up wherever she would find herself.
So, I let the cops in. “Are you Jack Miller?” they asked roughly.
“Yes” I replied cautiously, “What’s going on?”
“You are under arrest for the murder of three people, and one attempted murder.”
I was shocked, to say the least. Three murders? Me? Under arrest? Oh my! I’ve never killed anyone! “What?” I cried, “How can this be happening?”
“We’ll tell ya at the station.” The gruff sounding cop said as the other policeman put me in handcuffs.
————-
I was sitting in the interrogation room when the detective walked in, with the girl right behind him. She didn’t look at me. Her face, though still dreary, looked almost guilty. Two adults that I later found out were her parents followed her in the door. They had looks of great fear on their faces, but I could see deep hatred in their eyes.
Detective Riley looked at me, “Miller, do you know this young girl? She says she’s a student in your class, is this true?”
“Yes” I answered confidently.
“Where were you tonight at 10:00 p.m.?” Riley asked,
“Home, watching T.V., I usually watch it to unwind after grading homework.”
“That’s real interesting, ’cause this girl here says you were in her bedroom and attempted. She managed to get away from you and by the time she alerted her parents, you were gone out her bedroom window.”
“That’s insane, there has to be some kind of misunderstanding!” I cried. This must be a bad dream…a nightmare!
He didn’t believe me, I knew it. I had no one that could vouch for me.
“So, you teach this little girl. Do you have access to the addresses of the children you teach?” Riley asked.
“No, but we have access to phone numbers in case we need to call the parents of a student.”
“Have you ever called or gone to this girl’s house?”
“No, I’ve never been there or seen her outside of school. We just used to talk after school. We are both lonely people, so we gave each other company.”
“Do you read the newspapers, Miller?”
“No, they are too depressing.”
“Have you heard anything about the person the media has named ‘The Psycho Park Killer’ “? Riley had a smug smirk on his face as he asked me this question, almost as if he already knew the answers to this line of questioning.
“I’ve heard some talk about him…oh my…please don’t tell me you think I’m a murderer? That I could do those things to innocent people!”
The Psycho Park Killer was a man who committed three murders. The victims had been strangled and dismembered, limb from limb. After my outburst, the little girl looked at me with that dark look in her eyes and on her face, and softly said, “We were friends Mr. Miller, why did you try to hurt me?”. For a moment, she almost looked like a normal 12 year old.
“Me? I would never hurt you! I am your friend!” I was getting more and more confused by the minute.
Detective Riley told the parents and the little girl to wait outside of the room. “Jack, we know it’s you. There’s no point denying it. Bob, escort him to his cell…and don’t be gentle.” I was handcuffed again and escorted from the interrogation room.
Bob certainly wasn’t gentle. He kept asking me why I did it. I kept telling him I was innocent. He threw me into the cell and the last thing I remember hearing was the slamming of the cold steel cell door.
————-
“Paul, where’s Ellie? I saw her head to the kitchen when we got home, but she’s not there now. Have you seen her?” asked a very worried mother.
“No, Marie, I haven’t. Maybe she’s in her room. Did you check?”
“No, I will now though”. Marie headed up the stairs to look for her daughter.
————-
They won’t find me in my room. I’m in the basement looking over my keepsakes. The sharp knife that I used in the murders. My knife. The momentos I took from my victims. I laughed quietly, so they wouldn’t hear me, and find me looking over my trophies and call that horrible hospital again. The story I made up about Mr. Miller was the best. I’m free. But I find myself strangely upset that Mr. Miller will be getting all the credit for my hard work. Can I really just sit back and let him get all the glory…all my glory?
————-
I will tell you what happened after that night. Jack Miller was put on trial and convicted. He was sentenced to death. As I sit here in the electric chair, Jack Miller is gone and I am in his place. I was always there, I created Jack Miller. I stayed lurking in the hidden recesses of the mind Jack thought belonged to him. I stayed waiting for the perfect moments to perform my works of art. Jack never knew about me or the works of art I worked on. My only disappointment is that I only received the credit for three of my creations. There are so many more that no one knows of…and so many more could have been created!
I will tell you about the little girl. She thought she had committed the murders. My murders. She was crazy. Sick. She tried to take all the credit for the atrocities that I alone was responsible for. Ellie decided she wouldn’t be lonely anymore if she had a lot of attention from the police and the newspapers. So, she retold the stories that I had told her during our special time after school, putting herself in my place at all the gory, murderous and bloody moments. I would not allow her crass claim for glory. The glory should be mine, all mine.
She’s now back in the hospital where she lived before. She was put there after her parents really saw for the first time the inner working of her twisted mind. She’ll be locked away in that asylum for a long, long time.
As for me, the doctor said I have split personalities. I can tell you that is not true. Jack Miller was a persona I created so I could slip under the radar while I created my masterpieces. Jack Miller is gone. I am here. I love killing. It thrills and excites me. I’ve become obsessed with it. But I was never perfect. Yet, within the next few moments, I shall perform my tour-de-force: my own death. I will remain vexed at my own imperfection until the exact minute I feel my soul leave my body.





